Hate Me Like You Love Me book cover

Character Study · Characters

Old Wounds Divide the Leads of Hate Me Like You Love Me

Character Study · My Passion editorial team ·

About the book
8.0/10Characters
Heroine8.0
Love interest7.0
Conflict between them9.0
Narrative voice8.0

Serena is a guarded planner; Caleb is the familiar boy whose cruelty makes him dangerous to trust. The leads of Hate Me Like You Love Me are connected by childhood and family, not a chance meeting. Serena’s first-person narration gives her the clearest initial presence, while Caleb arrives through his reputation, her memories, and the response she wishes she could suppress.

Serena wants a future she can shape

The first things Serena names are SAT preparation and college essays. I like that introduction because it gives her a life beyond Caleb before he takes over her attention. She wants the summer before senior year to belong to her. Being sent to find him feels like an intrusion on that claim.

The blurb explains why control matters so much. Her mother died of cancer, her father moved on too fast, and home no longer feels secure. The editorial description frames her reserve and sexual inexperience as self-preservation rather than simple innocence. Together, those details establish a heroine protecting herself, not merely waiting for someone to change her life.

Her behavior in the opening also complicates any assumption that quiet means passive. Internally, she is furious, observant, and funny. She may comply with Catherine’s request, but she has plenty to say about it.

Caleb’s characters and masks are not the same thing

Caleb’s introduction is deliberately uncomfortable. His lacrosse photograph displays a confident smirk; Serena associates it with years of private cruelty. The contrast establishes a boy whose visible success and family manners do not tell her story of him.

The blurb connects his rake persona to violence he escaped as a child. The editorial description adds that being wanted physically feels easier to him than being known. Those details suggest a defense built around desirability and recklessness. They give readers a reason to ask what he is hiding, but not a reason to dismiss what he has done.

Chapter 1 does not enter his perspective or show remorse. His capacity for change belongs to the premise’s redemption question, rather than to any demonstrated transformation.

The families see closeness; Serena remembers harm

Catherine’s place as Serena’s godmother makes the conflict especially personal. These families expected their children to grow up close, and Serena says they never noticed when things went wrong. That leaves her carrying a private account of Caleb inside a public story of togetherness.

For the relationship to become persuasive, trust would need to mean more than discovering his wounds. Serena’s right to protect herself matters too. Hate Me Like You Love Me makes that tension central to its character setup: understanding someone and feeling safe with them are different things.

Serena’s voice keeps the introduction sharp

The repeated frustration over one favor gives her narration a wonderfully specific grievance. She resents the errand, notices Caleb’s public image, recognizes his laugh, and argues with herself about leaving. Those small contradictions make her memorable. We do not need to know her eventual choices to understand how divided her attention already is.

What works

  • Serena has concrete ambitions beyond the romance.
  • Her irritation gives the opening a distinct personality.
  • The difference between family appearances and private hurt sharpens the conflict.

May not suit you if

  • Caleb’s vulnerability is described in the premise rather than shown in the opening.
  • Readers seeking an immediately reassuring love interest may struggle with his introduction.

Bottom line: 8.0/10

Serena makes the stronger first impression because chapter 1 gives direct access to her frustration, ambition, and self-protection. Caleb is compelling as a troubling question rather than an established romantic partner: his backstory invites curiosity, while her memories keep his cruelty firmly in view.

Our reviews are based on the book's premise, its opening chapter and reader data from the My Passion app – no spoilers beyond the blurb.