
Voice Check · Voice & Style
Voice Check: Lily’s Quiet, Honest Narration in My Secret Deal
Voice Check · My Passion editorial team ·
About the bookPoint of view and distance
The story is told in first person by Lily, and the distance is close. We are given her plans, her noticing and her decision not to say what she notices. Yan Stellar makes smart use of that closeness: the reader sees the small signs of Travis pulling away before Lily lets herself admit them, which makes the narration feel honest in an almost uncomfortable way.
The perspective also leaves space for the reader to know a little more than Lily says aloud. She tells us she noticed everything and said nothing, so we are in the position of waiting for the moment she stops pretending.
Tone
The tone is soft, rueful and a little self-deprecating. The opening line sets it up with understatement: summer had barely started, and she already felt like she was falling apart. It is not melodramatic. It is the tone of someone who is used to turning her feelings down so nobody else has to deal with them.
That restraint is what makes the emotional beats work. When you read a narrator who does not shout, quiet moments carry more weight, and it suits a book that the editorial notes call emotional and character-driven.
Clarity and pace of the sentences
The writing is easy to follow. Paragraphs are short, thoughts arrive one at a time, and conversation does a lot of the work, such as the exchange with Erin about showing up unannounced. The pace is gentle but steady: a plan, a conversation, a lie to her mother, and out the door, all in a small number of beats.
The ellipses and sentence fragments in the dialogue give it a natural, teenage rhythm. Nothing in the chapter asks the reader to stop and untangle meaning, so the story moves quickly even while the mood stays reflective.
Personality on the page
What gives this voice its personality is a pattern: a short, specific statement followed by an even shorter one that lands harder. "My boyfriend. My safe space." And then, "Or at least, he used to be that guy." That quick turn from certainty to doubt is the voice in miniature, and it makes Lily feel like a real person narrating her own life.
Her line "That's not what I do" is the heart of it. It tells you who she is, who she has been trained to be and who the story intends to challenge. If you like narrators whose quiet habits become the plot, this voice will feel quite distinctive.
What works
- Immediate first-person voice with very clear thoughts
- Short, readable sentences and good dialogue rhythm
- A gentle tone that fits a YA readership
May not suit you if
- Not for readers who prefer lyrical or experimental prose
- Less suited if you want a big, loud narrator from page one
Bottom line: 8.0/10
A close, confiding first-person voice that makes people-pleasing feel specific. Plain, readable and quietly personal.
Our reviews are based on the book's premise, its opening chapter and reader data from the My Passion app – no spoilers beyond the blurb.