I Love You Since 1892 (Book 1) book cover

I Love You Since 1892 (Book 1) Reviews

by Binibining Mia

7.7/10Overall

Spice

Spice level 1 of 5

A fiery modern heroine meets a family mystery reaching back to 1892.

The short version

Carmela makes her entrance by tearing up a party invitation and provoking a classmate. That combative first impression belongs to a much larger setup: a birthday visit to San Alfonso, an unsettling family mansion, and a portrait of Carmelita, a woman who looks exactly like her. The blurb connects Carmela from 2016 with Juanito from 1892, whose romance with Carmelita is governed by a family agreement.

The appeal is the combination of an outspoken narrator, inherited expectations, and a mystery across time. Chapter 1 contains no romantic intimacy or interaction between the leads, so the opening spice rating is low. Listed as completed with 17 chapters, Book 1 suits readers willing to meet the heroine before meeting the romance.

Best for

  • Readers who enjoy outspoken heroines with rough edges
  • Fans of family mysteries, old mansions, and portraits with a personal connection
  • Romance readers drawn to arranged relationships and encounters across time

Maybe not for you if

  • You want the romantic leads together in the first scene
  • You prefer a gentle narrator to a deliberately provocative one
  • You want time-crossing rules established immediately

Editorial angles

7.3/10Spice & Chemistry
Heat level7.0
Tension7.0
Chemistry7.0
Power dynamics8.0

Chapter 1 has no romantic intimacy: its sparks come from a classroom feud. The family agreement and encounter across time promise relationship complications, but neither the couple's chemistry nor the book's eventual heat is established.

Read the review →
7.8/10Characters
Heroine8.0
Love interest7.0
Conflict between them8.0
Narrative voice8.0

Carmela is the opening's clearest personality: impatient, confrontational, and unwilling to hide her dislike. Carmelita, Juanito, and Lola Carmina have intriguing roles in the setup, but their motives and voices are not established in chapter 1.

Read the review →
8.0/10Binge Factor
Addictiveness8.0
Emotional pull7.0
Readability8.0
Worth the length9.0

Worth trying if an abrasive heroine and an inherited mystery appeal to you. The completed 17-chapter listing lowers the uncertainty around updates, but chapter 1 tests your interest in Carmela rather than delivering the historical romance immediately.

Read the review →
7.5/10World & Lore
Setting8.0
Rules of the world7.0
Atmosphere8.0
Immersion7.0

The setting's appeal lies in contrast: a modern classroom introduces the historical date, while the mansion and family agreement promise a more intimate encounter with the past. The atmosphere is established more clearly than the rules of crossing time.

Read the review →

Our reviews are based on the book's premise, its opening chapter and reader data from the My Passion app – no spoilers beyond the blurb.