
The Heat Check · Spice & Chemistry
Why I Love You Since 1892 (Book 1) Opens Without Romantic Heat
The Heat Check · My Passion editorial team ·
About the bookThe opening spice level is low in I Love You Since 1892 (Book 1): chapter 1 contains a classroom confrontation, not romantic intimacy. Its energy comes from Carmela's temper. The romantic invitation lies elsewhere, in a family-arranged relationship from 1892 and the promise that a woman from 2016 will encounter its hero across time.
Spice level: no intimacy in the classroom
There is no kiss, sexual encounter, or flirtation in chapter 1. Carmela is sitting through a Philippine History lecture when a party invitation reaches her. She tears it up, antagonizes Shae, and makes her exit after sticking gum to Shae's desk. There is plenty of hostility here, but it would be a stretch to call it romantic tension.
The listing rates the book 16. That is useful reading guidance, not a substitute for knowing what happens between the leads. A low rating for opening spice should not be mistaken for a promise that the entire book stays closed-door.
Family duty supplies the romantic pressure
The blurb places Carmelita and Juanito inside an agreement between the Montecarlos and Alfonso families. Their romance is therefore a family matter before readers see it become a personal one. That is the strongest relationship complication established by the premise: other people have a stake in how this pairing unfolds.
Carmela's encounter with Juanito adds a different question. She belongs to 2016; he belongs to 1892. Her resemblance to Carmelita and their matching birth date make the connection intriguing, but those clues tell us nothing yet about attraction, trust, or physical closeness.
Chemistry must wait for the leads to meet
Carmela's personality is much easier to assess than her romantic chemistry. She is impatient, judgmental, and quite prepared to make an already awkward situation worse. That gives her presence, although a forceful narrator does not automatically make a convincing romantic pairing.
I let out a sigh.
Even that small reaction belongs to annoyance at the invitation, not yearning. The distinction matters if you are choosing a book primarily for its heat. The opening offers attitude; the blurb offers the possibility of a complicated love story. It has not yet put those ingredients together on the page.
What to expect from the relationship setup
- Opening heat: No romantic or sexual intimacy appears in chapter 1.
- External pressure: A family agreement dictates Carmelita and Juanito's romance.
- Unanswered boundaries: Their feelings about that agreement, including how freely they choose each other, remain unknown.
Choose I Love You Since 1892 (Book 1) for romantic anticipation tied to a family puzzle, rather than for demonstrated heat. Readers who enjoy discovering why two people are connected may find that enough of an invitation. Those shopping specifically for high heat will need more than this opening to judge the fit.
What works
- The family agreement gives the romantic premise a clear source of pressure.
- Carmela's connection to Carmelita adds curiosity beyond physical attraction.
- The opening establishes a forceful heroine before introducing her romantic dynamics.
May not suit you if
- Readers seeking immediate attraction will not find it in the classroom opening.
- The age rating alone cannot establish the romance's eventual heat or boundaries.
Bottom line: 7.3/10
Chapter 1 has no romantic intimacy: its sparks come from a classroom feud. The family agreement and encounter across time promise relationship complications, but neither the couple's chemistry nor the book's eventual heat is established.
Our reviews are based on the book's premise, its opening chapter and reader data from the My Passion app – no spoilers beyond the blurb.