
Character Study · Characters
Carmela Makes Her Entrance in I Love You Since 1892 (Book 1)
Character Study · My Passion editorial team ·
About the bookCarmela dominates the introduction to I Love You Since 1892 (Book 1), and she does it by behaving badly rather than politely asking for sympathy. Her classroom clash establishes a quick temper and a taste for provocation. Carmelita and Juanito supply the historical romantic connection, while Lola Carmina brings questions into the modern family setting.
Carmela wants more say over her life
The editorial introduction describes a young woman frustrated by her father's expectations and grieving her mother. Those circumstances matter, but chapter 1 does not ask readers to excuse her through them. It lets her make an uncompromising first impression.
She tears up a party invitation, glares at Shae, and sticks gum to her desk before leaving. These are choices, not just sarcastic observations. Carmela can be amusingly blunt, but she is also escalating the conflict. Readers who enjoy a heroine with room to grow may appreciate that distinction.
Carmelita is more than a resemblance
Carmelita is the youngest Montecarlos daughter in 1892. Her romance with Juanito is dictated by an agreement between their families. That gives her a position within the story, though not yet an individual voice.
Carmela shares her birth date and looks exactly like her. The portrait discovery described in the editorial introduction turns that resemblance into a personal mystery. Still, looking alike is not evidence that the women have the same temperament, desires, or choices. Those differences remain something to watch for.
Juanito arrives first as a question
The son of the powerful Alfonso clan, Juanito belongs to the historical romance and to Carmela's encounter across time. It is a striking role for a romantic lead: he connects the two women without the blurb explaining how.
Chapter 1 does not show whether he is tender, arrogant, reluctant, or eager about the family agreement. Assigning him any of those traits would get ahead of the story. His circumstances are intriguing; his personality is still to come.
Lola Carmina gives the mansion a human mystery
Carmela's grandmother wants to introduce her to someone hidden within the mansion, according to the editorial introduction. Her unusual attention makes the house's unease personal. There is a family member behaving strangely, not merely an unfamiliar building.
Her reasons remain unstated. That makes Lola Carmina a useful source of curiosity without establishing whether she is protective, secretive, or pursuing some other intention.
Family pressure links the characters
Carmela resents her father's expectations; Carmelita and Juanito have a relationship governed by their families' agreement. These are different situations, but both place individual wishes beside inherited obligations. The opening has not yet shown how the romantic leads negotiate that pressure.
A narrator who refuses to soften her opinions
The first-person voice is the clearest reason to sample I Love You Since 1892 (Book 1). Carmela judges the professor, James, and Shae in quick succession. Her narration moves with her irritation.
That sharpness will be a pleasure for some readers and a barrier for others. The useful test is not whether you approve of everything she does, but whether you want to stay close enough to understand her.
What works
- Carmela's deliberate provocations give her a sharply defined first impression.
- Grief and family expectations add context beyond her classroom behavior.
- Carmelita's likeness to Carmela makes the historical cast personally relevant.
May not suit you if
- Readers wanting equal access to both romantic leads will need to wait.
- Carmela's treatment of Shae may not suit readers who prefer immediately gentle heroines.
Bottom line: 7.8/10
Carmela is the opening's clearest personality: impatient, confrontational, and unwilling to hide her dislike. Carmelita, Juanito, and Lola Carmina have intriguing roles in the setup, but their motives and voices are not established in chapter 1.
Our reviews are based on the book's premise, its opening chapter and reader data from the My Passion app – no spoilers beyond the blurb.