I Love You Since 1892 (Book 1) book cover

Binge Factor · Binge Factor

Should I Love You Since 1892 (Book 1) Be Your Next Read?

Binge Factor · My Passion editorial team ·

About the book
8.0/10Binge Factor
Addictiveness8.0
Emotional pull7.0
Readability8.0
Worth the length9.0

Yes, I Love You Since 1892 (Book 1) is worth trying if a combative heroine and a family mystery sound more inviting than an immediate romantic encounter. Carmela's classroom behavior gives you a quick taste of her voice. The completed, 17-chapter listing also means you can begin without waiting for further updates to this book.

Worth reading tonight if Carmela catches your interest

The quickest test is the first scene. Carmela is bored in a history lecture, receives a party invitation, and chooses to make her dislike obvious. Soon there are torn pieces of paper, a reprimand from the professor, and gum stuck to a desk.

If that sounds entertaining, the narrator may carry you into the larger premise. If it sounds exhausting, take the reaction seriously. A first-person story keeps you close to its narrator, and Carmela does not begin by trying to charm everyone.

The reason to continue beyond that scene is specific: a birthday visit to San Alfonso connects her with a woman who looks exactly like her and with Juanito from 1892. The editorial introduction's portrait and hidden passage add concrete objects of curiosity.

Read it if these are your evening-reading pleasures

  • You enjoy outspoken heroines whose behavior can be provocative.
  • You like old houses, family secrets, and discoveries with a personal connection.
  • You want a romance premise that moves between a modern life and 1892.
  • You prefer a book listed as completed rather than one awaiting updates.

Consider another opening if you want something gentler

  • You want the romantic leads interacting in the first scene.
  • You prefer a narrator who handles conflict with restraint.
  • You want the rules of the encounter across time explained immediately.

The opening's energy is confrontational rather than tender. Carmela's grief and frustration with her father appear in the editorial setup, but the classroom excerpt is not an extended emotional introduction. Its job is to make her attitude unmistakable.

Seventeen chapters, without a promised reading time

The chapter count offers a useful boundary, but it does not tell us how long each installment is. I would not turn it into a promise that you can finish in one sitting. Likewise, a completed status establishes publication status, not the resolution of every romantic or historical question.

A sensible approach is to sample chapter 1 for voice, then use the blurb to decide whether the family connection interests you enough to continue. Those are two distinct attractions: enjoying Carmela's company and wanting answers about Carmelita and Juanito.

For me, the strongest reason to try I Love You Since 1892 (Book 1) is that the mystery belongs to the heroine's own family. The portrait is not just an intriguing object; it confronts her with her own likeness. That is a good question to carry into another chapter, even before the romance begins.

What works

  • The classroom confrontation offers a quick test of whether Carmela's voice suits you.
  • The portrait and encounter across time provide specific questions to follow.
  • Book 1 is listed as completed, with 17 chapters.

May not suit you if

  • Readers choosing solely for immediate romance may find the opening less inviting.
  • Chapter count does not establish reading time or guarantee closure for every mystery.

Bottom line: 8.0/10

Worth trying if an abrasive heroine and an inherited mystery appeal to you. The completed 17-chapter listing lowers the uncertainty around updates, but chapter 1 tests your interest in Carmela rather than delivering the historical romance immediately.

Our reviews are based on the book's premise, its opening chapter and reader data from the My Passion app – no spoilers beyond the blurb.